---
title: 2028: App Clip payment cards can only be sent over iMessage | API Docs
description: An app_clip part was sent while SMS or RCS was explicitly requested.
---

App Clip payment cards can only be sent over iMessage. The request included an `app_clip` part while explicitly requesting SMS or RCS. This is an HTTP 409 error.

## Troubleshooting

- Omit `preferred_service` — it defaults to iMessage for App Clip cards — or set it to `iMessage`
- App Clip cards never fall back to SMS/RCS. If the recipient isn’t reachable over iMessage, the send instead fails asynchronously with a `message.failed` webhook carrying code [4005](/error/codes/4xxx/4005/index.md)
- [Check iMessage capability](/guides/messaging/protocol-selection#protocol-capabilities/index.md) before sending

## Related

- [Sending payment links](/guides/payments/sending-payment-links/index.md)
- [Protocol Selection](/guides/messaging/protocol-selection/index.md)
- [Error Codes](/error/index.md)